In Safe Space, Hanhardt provides an overview of San Francisco and New York City as case studies of contradictions between ethnic groups and gay communities—San Francisco experienced tensions between the Mission District and the Castro, while New York City saw conflicts among different ethnic groups. Hanhardt grounds the discussion in the impact of Reagan’s presidency and how his policies affected these areas, providing examples of organizations that stood up to address these contradictions. Hanhardt’s essay highlights how racial divisions surfaced in queer spaces and how different racial and ethnic groups have competed for resources and space.
In That’s My Place!, Horacio Roque Ramirez introduces GALA in San Francisco as a case study—a pioneering organization that sought to challenge both the white-dominated gay community and Latino spaces. Although the founders imagined a space where gender, racial, and sexual identities could coexist, conflicts soon arose as the white gay community moved into and further gentrified the Mission District, where GALA’s members socialized. Additionally, tensions emerged between lesbian members and the broader gay community within GALA, as many lesbians did not feel welcomed. Although GALA was founded with the intention of uniting intersecting identities, it eventually dissolved due to both external pressures from the white gay community and internal tensions, including those with lesbian members.
Across the two readings, themes of the white gay community moving into and gentrifying neighborhoods are silimar and both authors have revealed the challenges of building a community that supports both one’s sexual and ethnic identities. The question remains: since previous efforts have struggled to build communities that meet both needs, how can we move forward in supporting people’s ethnic and sexual identities simultaneously? Where can we learn from these failures, and how can we truly build inclusive spaces that support diverse communities? And where can we locate these community?
Leave a Reply