Mise-en-scène – Is Lighting Really Everything?

Mise-en-scène – the art of presenting a scene to the audience.
There are five components that make up mise-en-scène: lighting, composition, costumes, setting, makeup, and staging. There are hundreds of individual ways to illuminate your stage and therefore evoke certain emotions. It consists of quality, direction, and source, and color also plays a big role when shaping the atmosphere. When reading chapter 4, I was amazed by the focus put on lighting. And as the text states: “No component of mise-en-scène is more important than what Sternberg called ‘the drama and adventure of light’” (p. 132). But is light really the most essential aspect of mise-en-scène? Isn’t every element of great importance? Perhaps sometimes more weight is placed on lighting, in another case on staging, and in yet another on framing.

As an example of how mise-en-scène can create fear and unease, I want to look at a scene from my favorite movie – Stanley Kubrick’s The Shining.
In this sequence, we follow Danny riding his bike through the corridors of the Overlook Hotel. After riding for a while, he suddenly stops after turning a corner and sees two girls standing at the other end of the corridor, staring at him.

For the setting, we have the long and symmetrical hallway. The camera is centered behind Danny, focusing on the motionless twins at the far end of the corridor, who are staring at both Danny and the camera. Furthermore, the emphasis on the girls is enhanced by all the vanishing lines leading to them – our eyes are naturally drawn to this point. This setting evokes an uncomfortable and claustrophobic atmosphere.

The two girls are both wearing old-fashioned dresses, making them appear ghostly and implying that they belong to another time and should not be in this hotel. Additionally, the light-blue color of their dresses match the darker blue carpet and the white/light-blue walls. This suggests that the girls are, in fact, part of the Overlook Hotel (which they are, if you haven’t seen the movie or read the book) and therefore personify the horrors that have happened in the past. Through the color scheme, they visually merge with the hotel. In contrast to them, Danny is wearing a bright red sweater.

The top lighting, the source of which is part of the set design, also contributes to making the scene frightening. It comes straight from above, is harsh and cold, and creates an unpleasant feeling.

I would argue that the composition, setting, and choice of costumes are the most impactful aspects of mise-en-scène that make this scene terrifying. Of course, lighting also supports this feeling, but I can imagine many different lighting arrangements that wouldn’t diminish the sense of unease created here.

Do you agree with me, or do you think I underestimate the impact of lighting in this scene?

Comments

2 responses to “Mise-en-scène – Is Lighting Really Everything?”

  1. Ethan Zuo Avatar
    Ethan Zuo

    I would absolutely agree with your point about the lighting in The Shining. In that hallway scene, lighting is the decisive element, the fading light and leading towards the twin siter dominates the unease, while the other aspects, such as the environment, their costume, and composition are only supporting elements of that scene. The harsh top lighting adds discomfort and fear to the audience. However, I think the importance of lighting really changes depending on the circumstance.

    One example to support your idea is the Godfather. In this particular scene, light is shed down from the top, creating heavy shadow on the character’s eyes. This creates a heavy suspense. And by plunging half of the character’s face into shadows, the shot communicates secrecy and menace. Without the light shedding from above, the director will give us another sense of feeling, and the character will give us different impressions. (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dcttwC-NXKk you can watch this video for the scene, I pick it up from the textbook).

    Another example that can be the counter of it, is the Jurassic Park series. This series is basically talking about big dinosaurs going wild and killing people. Overall in this series, light only serves as illumination. What’s really terrifying us is the sound, environment, and the digitally created dinosaurs.

    So I would agree with you that in The Shining hallway scene, light plays a crucial role. But in all cases combined, we see that in one case lighting can recede, while in another it defines the entire atmosphere.

    1. Valentin Krenn Avatar
      Valentin Krenn

      Hey Ethan, I think there was a little misunderstanding haha. I think the lighting in the scene from The Shining is NOT the decisive element that creates fear and unease. It’s rather the composition, setting and the costumes in my opinion. Of course lighting plays a crucial role in other scenes (e.g. the scene from Godfather you wrote about), but still we agree on that lighting is not fundamentaly the most important aspect of mise-en-scene.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *