Cancer: Evolutionary Fact or Fiction?

Contributed by Nicholas Eyrich, Jordan Feltes, Eric Ni, Somnath Das, Noah Steigelfest, and Evan Dackowski.

Cancer Heredity

Misconception: It is commonly perceived that cancer is hereditary, and one can either not have cancer in their family, thinking they are fine or have family members diagnosed and think it is a matter of time before they contract the disease.

Truth: Both of these notions grossly overlook the fact that most cancers are sporadic, meaning their onset is not due to family history, but rather due to gen1etic mutations and environmental exposures during one’s lifetime. Cancer is not heritable, but a predisposition to the disease can be (Peltomaki, 2012). For example, in our DNA we have two copies of each tumor suppressor gene, one from each parent. These genes keep cells from growing uncontrollably. So to lose function, one has to have mutations in both copies. Unfortunately, one can be born with a mutation in one copy, such as in Retinoblastoma (Rb). This means the gene is still expressed using the normal copy, but this confers a 50% increased predisposition for the disease bringing cells halfway closer to being cancer cells (Price et al., 2014).

Evolutionary Cancer Mutations

Misconception: It takes one bad mutation in one cell to get cancer, and cancer is one disease with all of cells in a tumor being equal.

Truth: Population biology is used to describe tumor growth and spread (metastasis), rather than arising from a single “bad” cell. Actually, it takes on average six to seven cumulative mutations (less in pediatric cancers) to confer disease, each one having been selected for during the previous cell generation. When mutations happen and build upon each other, the combination of changes can lead to cancer. (Yamamoto, Nakamura, & Haeno, 2015). Illustrated below. This supports cancer mostly being a disease of old age, as mutations take time to accumulate. Cancer essentially consists of many diseases that continue to harass the brains of researchers. Essentially, doctors have been able to treat for certain mutations, but once one important mutation is treated, another one can take over to drive relapse (Landau et al., 2015). Also, in tumors there ar2e different environments around cells fostering different mutations in various areas of the same tumor (Hardiman et al., 2015). Cancer is adapting to therapies that target mutations, making it so difficult to control.

DNA Damage

Misconception: DNA damage is rare, and we have little protection against it. Most cancer-causing agents (carcinogens) are processed chemicals not naturally found in nature.

Truth: DNA damage happens many times per day and our bodies have also evolved repair mechanisms in response to the need to correct such damage. In addition, the vast majority of cancer causin3g agents are naturally occurring substances we encounter on a daily basis (Bauer, Corbett, & Doetsch, 2015). The human body has evolved ways to counteract DNA-damaging events, for example during sunlight exposure, using molecular machinery and likewise other naturally occurring compounds (Nishisgori, 2015).



Bauer, Nicholas C., Anita H. Corbett, and Paul W. Doetsch. “The Current State of Eukaryotic DNA Base Damage and Repair.” Nucleic Acids Res Nucleic Acids Research (2015): n. pag. Web.

Hardiman, Karin M., Peter J. Ulintz, Rork D. Kuick, Daniel H. Hovelson, Christopher M. Gates, Ashwini Bhasi, Ana Rodrigues Grant, Jianhua Liu, Andi K. Cani, Joel K. Greenson, Scott A. Tomlins, and Eric R. Fearon. “Intra-tumor Genetic Heterogeneity in Rectal Cancer.” Lab Invest Laboratory Investigation (2015): n. pag. Web.

Landau, Dan A., Eugen Tausch, Amaro N. Taylor-Weiner, Chip Stewart, Johannes G. Reiter, Jasmin Bahlo, Sandra Kluth, Ivana Bozic, Mike Lawrence, Sebastian Böttcher, Scott L. Carter, Kristian Cibulskis, Daniel Mertens, Carrie L. Sougnez, Mara Rosenberg, Julian M. Hess, Jennifer Edelmann, Sabrina Kless, Michael Kneba, Matthias Ritgen, Anna Fink, Kirsten Fischer, Stacey Gabriel, Eric S. Lander, Martin A. Nowak, Hartmut Döhner, Michael Hallek, Donna Neuberg, Gad Getz, Stephan Stilgenbauer, and Catherine J. Wu. “Mutations Driving CLL and Their Evolution in Progression and Relapse.” Nature 526.7574 (2015): 525-30. Web.

Nishisgori, Chikako. “Current Concept of Photocarcinogenesis.” Photochem. Photobiol. Sci. 14.9 (2015): 1713-721. Web.

Peltomäki, Päivi. “Mutations and Epimutations in the Origin of Cancer.” Experimental Cell Research 318.4 (2012): 299-310. Web.

Price, E. A., K. Price, K. Kolkiewicz, S. Hack, M. A. Reddy, J. L. Hungerford, J. E. Kingston, and Z. Onadim. “Spectrum of RB1 Mutations Identified in 403 Retinoblastoma Patients.” Journal of Medical Genetics 51.3 (2013): 208-14. Web.

Weinberg, Robert A. The Biology of Cancer. New York: Garland Science, 2007. Print.

Yamamoto, Kimiyo N., Akira Nakamura, and Hiroshi Haeno. “The Evolution of Tumor Metastasis during Clonal Expansion with Alterations in Metastasis Driver Genes.” Sci. Rep. Scientific Reports5 (2015): 15886. Web.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *